If you’re considering entering the home music recording game, you’ve undoubtedly begun what can be a difficult decision process to select the right home studio software to fit your needs. There is no shortage of available products, and there is enough skin in the game to make the decision somewhat daunting. We’ll take a look at the two premier products in the genre to help you make an educated buying decision.
First, we’ll consider the flagship product from industry giant Digidesign, called Pro Tools HD. It’s a one-stop solution to fit most recording, mixing, editing, and production needs, with a very impressive list of features and functions. Just like every major music recording software product on the market, Pro Tools’ user interface requires a little time for adjustment and familiarity, but even neophytes will know their way around the major functions in a relatively short period of time. And there is a rich enough library of available editing and mixing tools to keep the professional audio engineer happy as well, evidenced by the list of professional recording artists whose music has been touched in some way by Pro Tools software.
The downside of Digidesign’s product line is that it requires external audio interface hardware to translate musical instrument and microphone signals into digital audio signals for processing. This can add cost and complexity to your home recording studio setup. But it also provides the opportunity to take advantage of distributed processing power, where external hardware performs some of the high-load processing (such as guitar effects) to free up your computer’s brains to accommodate more tracks.
Apple’s Logic Studio 9 is Digidesign’s major competition, and they’re gaining fast. Logic is more intuitive than Pro Tools, with a roughly equal feature set, and a unique interface environment that allows unprecedented flexibility in the signal path. The result is a very musician-friendly yet powerful and high quality musical recording software product. And the price is a bit nicer than Pro Tools, particularly when you consider that Logic is completely self-contained.
While your home studio software setup is a big decision, you will most likely be happy with your results using either Studio or Pro Tools.